050 Commentary

From Faith Futures
Jump to: navigation, search

This page forms part of the resources for 050 Harvest is Great in the Jesus Database project of FaithFutures Foundation

Crossan Inventory | 050 Literature | 050 Parallels | 050 Commentary | 050 Poetry | 050 Images


Commentary

John Dominic Crossan

Unlike his peers in the Jesus Seminar for which he was co-chair, Crossan considers this saying to be authentic and locates it within Jesus engagement in a social program that involved sending his followers out to announce and implement the "open secret" by offering forgiveness and healing in exchange for hospitality and meal. (See Historical Jesus, esp. pp. 332-53)

International Q Project

IQP reconstructs the original Q saying as follows:

He said to his disciples: The harvest is plentiful, but the workers are few.
So ask the Lord of the harvest to dispatch workers into his harvest.



Jesus Seminar

The following passages were all voted Black by the Seminar:

Thom 73
Luke 10:2
Matt 9:37b-38
John 4:35b,38

The commentary in [The Five Gospels] suggests that the Fellows voted this saying black for the following reasons. First, the theme of harvest is commonly an eschatological interest, and not something typical of Jesus. Secondly, the saying was judged to come from the early Christian movement where missionary activity was common.

The Seminar's view that Jesus was not an apocalyptic prophet seems to have skewed its capacity to recognize any eschatological element in Jesus' sayings and acts, despite the central place given to the imperial rule of God. Unlike Crossan's more carefully nuanced position (see, for example, Birth of Christianity, 239-89) that distinguished between apocalyptic eschatology, ascetical eschatology, and ethical eschatology, the Seminar as a whole seemed unable to integrate an eschatological dimension into their view of Jesus. As noted above, Crossan also located the missionary activity of the earliest Jesus communities in the conscious social program of Jesus as an indigenous healer.

Gerd Lüdemann

Lüdemann [Jesus] (164) judges the saying to derive from the early community and not from Jesus.